Created in 1987, Harry Caray’s is rooted in Chicago history and moreover, based in sports lure. Amazingly, in the 4 plus years of Steaks and Cigars, we have not been to this fine establishment. Let’s get into the review:

BATTING PRACTICE (DRINKS):
Brad, John and I elbowed up to a high boy and tasted the delicious kettle chips that are presented to the table. Delicious – so much so, they can ruin your hunger for the main course. In due time, Chris arrived from the airport (points for best effort to attend) and Father Cole returned for his first steak night since the birth of Simone. Glick was on time and we made for the table promptly at 8.

EARLY INNINGS (Apps/ Service/ Atmosphere):
Sadly, the dining room was nearly empty and the vibe was low key. That said, the boys were in good form and provided energy enough for the whole place. We were welcomed by our server Steve, who I must say was one of our top 5 to date. Knowledgeable on the history of the place, candid in feedback on dishes and not over the top in pushing us to more expensive items – Note: although we ordered two ravioli – he only delivered one, so as to not over fill on aps. The ravioli was tremendous, good calamari and positive meat and cheese board – a first for steak night.

MIDDLE INNINGS: (Where dining establishments win and lose):
Great pace to the night – our steaks were promptly prepared. I had the dry aged ny strip – flavored nicely with a salt and pepper rub, nothing too fancy. All was well – with the exception of Chris, who found his steak lacking in proper temp and overall flavor. Unfortunately, the sides were lackluster. Creamed spinach had little flavor, potatoes and mac n’ cheese were moderate – the brussel sprouts with bacon stole the show.

ENTER SANDMAN – CLOSER:
Fitting that the day before Mariano Rivera retired, we closed strong. Hans joined us for desert after his romp at he real estate awards. We had flourless chocolate cake, key lime pie and the show stopper peanut butter and snickers pie. We celebrated Glick’s actual birthday and rejoiced an evening of brotherhood.

Sadly, Scott was in NYC and Rick was prepping for an interview – still – good night at a new place. Looking forward to baseball season

Rating 6.5

Filed under: General | 5 Comments »